ER or Urgent Care? How to Decide, and What Urgent Care Can Handle
When the choice is not obvious — a hard fall, a knock to the head, a headache unlike your usual one — this guide gives the warning signs that mean 911 or the emergency room, where the line falls for everyday problems at UrgentMed’s Davie and Plantation clinics, and what to try when you are still not sure.
For the everyday illnesses and minor injuries both clinics treat, see urgent care for illness and injury; for the clinics themselves, see urgent care in Davie and Plantation.

Call 911 for heart attack and stroke signs
With a possible heart attack or stroke, call 911 right away, not urgent care. CDC lists the major symptoms of a heart attack as:
- Chest pain or discomfort.
- Feeling weak, light-headed or faint.
- Pain or discomfort in the jaw, neck or back.
- Pain or discomfort in one or both arms or shoulders.
- Shortness of breath.
Women are more likely to also have unusual tiredness and nausea or vomiting, CDC adds. For a stroke, CDC uses the B.E. F.A.S.T. test:
- B — Balance. Sudden loss of balance, or feeling dizzy.
- E — Eyes. Sudden trouble seeing normally.
- F — Face. Ask the person to smile. Does one side of the face droop?
- A — Arms. Ask them to raise both arms. Does one arm drift downward?
- S — Speech. Ask them to repeat a simple phrase. Is the speech slurred or strange?
- T — Time. Call 911 right away, and note the time the first symptom appeared.
With stroke signs, CDC says not to drive to the hospital or let someone else drive you, so that treatment can begin in the ambulance. The American Stroke Association says to call 911 even if the symptoms go away.
Other signs that belong in the emergency room
MedlinePlus, the National Library of Medicine’s site, puts it plainly: if a person could die or be permanently disabled, it is an emergency. Its lists of problems for 911 or an emergency department include:
- Breathing and bleeding. Choking, stopped breathing or severe shortness of breath; heavy bleeding, a deep wound or a serious burn; coughing or throwing up blood.
- Sudden changes. Sudden confusion, fainting, or suddenly being unable to speak, see, walk or move; dizziness or weakness that will not go away.
- Pain and injury. Severe pain anywhere in the body, pain in the arm or jaw, an unusual or bad headache (especially a sudden one), a possible broken bone with loss of movement or the bone pushing through the skin, or a neck or spine injury.
- Other. Seizures, a high fever with a headache and stiff neck, vomiting or loose stools that will not stop, poisoning or an overdose, or smoke or poisonous fumes breathed in.
A severe allergic reaction (anaphylaxis) is life-threatening. MedlinePlus lists difficulty breathing or wheezing, swelling of the face, eyes or tongue, and a very hoarse or whispered voice among its signs. Call 911 for severe symptoms, and if the person has epinephrine with them, it should be used right away.
If you are thinking about hurting yourself or others, call or text 988, or chat at 988lifeline.org. If someone has attempted suicide, call 911.
Head injuries: the danger signs that mean the ER
After a bump, blow or jolt to the head, CDC says to call 911 or go to the nearest emergency department for any of these danger signs:
- A headache that gets worse and does not go away.
- Repeated nausea or vomiting.
- Convulsions or seizures.
- Slurred speech, weakness, numbness or decreased coordination.
- Unusual behavior, increased confusion, restlessness or agitation.
- Not being able to recognize people or places.
- Loss of consciousness with increasing drowsiness, or being unable to wake up or stay awake.
- One pupil larger than the other, or double vision.
In infants and toddlers, CDC adds a child who will not stop crying and cannot be consoled, or who will not nurse or eat.
No special emergency room is needed. CDC’s advice is the nearest one, and any hospital emergency department that receives Medicare funds — most U.S. hospitals — must check you for an emergency medical condition. UrgentMed’s own page agrees: loss of consciousness, repeated vomiting, a worsening headache, confusion or a seizure after a head injury means the emergency room, not urgent care.
Without a danger sign, a provider at either clinic evaluates for concussion after a fall, a collision or a sports hit, documents the findings and gives written return-to-school, return-to-work or return-to-play guidance — for adults and children from age 3. Children under 3 are seen by their pediatrician, or in the emergency room if a danger sign appears.
What urgent care can handle
MedlinePlus describes the middle ground: a problem that is not life-threatening or risking disability, when you are concerned and cannot see your own provider soon enough. At UrgentMed that covers colds, flu and fever; sore throats, ear and sinus infections; UTIs; rashes; cuts that need stitches; sprains and simple fractures; minor burns; and asthma flare-ups in someone who is breathing comfortably — with X-ray, lab and EKG on site.
The “can urgent care…?” questions are answered one by one in what urgent care can do. For a child who is sick tonight, see where to take a sick child tonight.
Same symptom, two different doors
UrgentMed’s illness and injury page and resources guide draw the line like this:
- Burns. First-degree and small second-degree burns are cleaned, dressed and checked for infection here. A burn larger than your palm, on the face, hands, feet, genitals or a joint, or white, leathery or painless needs the emergency room.
- Headache. A migraine that is not responding to your usual medication is treated here. A sudden, worst-ever headache, or one with weakness, confusion or a stiff neck, is an emergency.
- Eyes. Red, itchy or crusted eyes and styes are examined and treated here. Sudden vision loss, severe eye pain, a chemical splash or an object embedded in the eye go to the emergency room or an ophthalmologist.
- Stomach. Stomach flu and food poisoning are evaluated here, with IV fluids when vomiting or diarrhea has led to dehydration. Severe or localized abdominal pain, blood in vomit or stool, or pain with a fever needs emergency evaluation.
- Back and joints. Strains and back or joint pain are examined and X-rayed when indicated; a suspected break is handled as sprains and fractures. Back pain with numbness in the legs, weakness, or loss of bladder or bowel control is an emergency.
- Breathing. An asthma flare-up in someone who is breathing comfortably is treated here with breathing treatments. Difficulty breathing is the emergency room.
- Allergic reactions. Rashes and hives are seen here. A severe reaction with swelling of the face or throat, or difficulty swallowing, is the emergency room.
- Cuts. A cut that needs stitches is treated here. Severe bleeding or a major injury is the emergency room.
If an emergency sign appears while you are at the clinic, tell the front desk or the provider at once.
Not sure which? How to decide in the moment
- Could it be one of the 911 signs above? Call 911. Don’t wait to be sure.
- No emergency signs? Call your own provider and describe your symptoms, as MedlinePlus suggests. After hours, the call may be forwarded to a nurse or provider on call.
- Nurse advice line. Your provider or health insurer may offer one.
- Still unsure, with no emergency signs? Walk in at Davie or Plantation, or start a telemedicine visit — but not for an emergency sign.
Ahead of time, MedlinePlus suggests saving five numbers in your phone: your provider, the closest emergency department, a nurse advice line, an urgent care clinic and a walk-in clinic.
At the emergency room: screening and insurance
Wondering which emergency room takes your insurance? In an emergency, go to the nearest one. CMS, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, sets out your rights there:
- A screening exam for everyone. Under the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act, a hospital emergency department that receives Medicare funds must offer a medical screening exam for an emergency medical condition, even if you have no insurance — and, if you have one, treat it until it is stabilized or arrange an appropriate transfer to another hospital.
- Insurance questions come second. The hospital can ask about health insurance when you check in, as long as it doesn’t delay your exam or treatment.
- Protection from surprise bills. If your plan covers emergency care, you can’t be charged more for emergency services than the in-network cost-sharing rate, and in most cases you are protected from unexpected out-of-network charges. Some health plans don’t cover emergency care; your insurance company can tell you what yours covers.
Call 911 or go to the nearest emergency department for chest pain or pressure, any B.E. F.A.S.T. stroke sign, severe trouble breathing, heavy bleeding, a head injury with a danger sign, a severe allergic reaction or a seizure. For a possible stroke, call 911 rather than driving. Thinking about hurting yourself or others? Call or text 988.
Walk in at Davie or Plantation
When it is not an emergency, walk in at UrgentMed Davie, 5149 S University Drive, or UrgentMed Plantation, 10199 Cleary Boulevard, Suite 10. No appointment is needed, and you can check in online to save your place. Adults and children from age 3 are seen at both clinics. Bring a photo ID and your insurance card. Check hours, maps and parking before you go.
Sources: CDC — Signs and symptoms of stroke (B.E. F.A.S.T.) · CDC — Heart attack symptoms, risk, and recovery · American Stroke Association — Stroke symptoms · CDC HEADS UP — Signs and symptoms of concussion · MedlinePlus — When to use the emergency room (adult) · MedlinePlus — Anaphylaxis · CMS — Emergency room rights · CMS — Know your rights when using insurance


